Calculation method and assumptions
Both paths begin with the greater of the two upfront cash requirements. Unused cash is invested. Each month both receive the same housing budget: the higher of the two monthly costs. The cheaper path invests the difference at month-end. [1]
Owner net wealth is the investment account plus modeled sale value, minus selling costs and remaining mortgage debt. Renter net wealth is the investment account plus the fully refunded deposit. Principal builds equity; a refundable deposit is an asset, not an expense. [2]
Home value and investments grow monthly from effective annual assumptions. Rent and other recurring costs change at each yearly anniversary. Property tax, insurance, maintenance and association costs follow the other-cost assumption. Mortgage insurance stays fixed until the entered duration or payoff. [2]
A positive buying advantage means higher modeled owner net wealth; a negative value favors renting. The first crossing can reverse. Taxes, investment fees, utilities, moving costs and lifestyle differences are excluded. Returns and price changes are scenarios, not forecasts. [2]
Worked example
With a home price of 120,000, a 20,000 down payment, a ten-year zero-interest loan and rent of 500, buying is ahead by 6,000 after one year if all growth, fees and other costs are zero.
Sources and references
- Rent or Buy: Which Option is Right for You? — Equity, maintenance, flexibility and the risks of changing home values in a rent-or-buy decision.
- Mortgage fees and costs when buying or selling a home — Account for transaction costs and recurring ownership expenses beyond the mortgage.
Sources reviewed: 18 November 2026